NFL Prop Bets: Pittsburgh Steelers vs Indianapolis Colts - Week 5

The Indianapolis Colts (2-2) face the Pittsburgh Steelers (2-2) at Acrisure Stadium for Week 5. Let's take a look at the NFL Prop Bets for Sunday's matchup. The Steelers are favored to win at -142, currently marked as 2.5-point favorites, while the Colts are at +120.

The total points line is set at 44.5, with OVER at -112 and UNDER at -108, meaning the implied expected score for the game is 24-21 Pittsburgh.

The Colts (-105) have a 3-1-0 ATS record this season, while the Steelers (-115) hold a record of 2-2-0.
The Colts have a 2-2-0 O/U record this season (meaning two games have gone over the total points line and two have gone under). The Steelers also have a 2-2-0 O/U record.

Points on the board

The Colts are averaging 25.5 points per game this season (13th in the league). Comparatively, the Steelers are averaging only 19.3 (23rd).
Defensively, the Colts are giving up 26.0 points per game this season (22nd in the league), while the Steelers are giving up an average of 21.8 points (14th).

Moving the chains

With an average of 284.3, the Colts rank 25th in the league for total yards per game. Comparatively, the Steelers rank 17th with 317.8 yards per game.
In terms of yards allowed, the Colts are giving up 392.3 per game this season (31st in the league), an inferior number to the Steelers, who are giving up an average of 322.3 (13th).

Ascendency in the air

The Colts have recorded 174.8 passing yards per game this season (26th in the league). Comparatively, the Steelers' defense has given up 209.5 passing yards per game (12th).
Meanwhile, the Steelers have recorded 223.0 passing yards per game this season (16th in the league), while the Colts' defense has given up 261.3 passing yards per game (29th).

Advantage on the ground

Looking at the ground game, the Colts have recorded 109.5 rushing yards per game this season (14th in the league). Conversely, the Steelers are giving up 112.8 rushing yards per game (17th).
On the other hand, the Steelers have recorded 94.8 rushing yards per game this season (22nd in the league), while the Colts are giving up 131.0 rushing yards per game (26th).

Protecting the ball

Looking at their ability to force turnovers, the Colts have recorded 2 total takeaways this season (T29th in the league), failing to perform to the same level as the Steelers, who have recorded 8 (T2nd).
On offense, the Colts have recorded 8 total giveaways this season (T26th in the league), while the Steelers have recorded 6 (T22nd).

First to Score

The Colts are -125 to score first, while the Steelers are -105.

The Colts have scored first in three of their four games this season.
The Steelers have also scored first in three of their four games.

Which team will score the first touchdown?

The Colts are +100 to record the first touchdown, while the Steelers are -120.

The Colts have recorded the first touchdown in each of their four games this season.
The Steelers have recorded the first touchdown in each of their two games this season.

First Scoring Play

Play	Frequency	Odds
Indianapolis Touchdown	2 / 4	+264
Indianapolis Field Goal	1 / 4	+263
Indianapolis Safety	0 / 4	+6300
Pittsburgh Touchdown	2 / 4	+253
Pittsburgh Field Goal	1 / 4	+309
Pittsburgh Safety	0 / 4	+6100

Which team will get a quick start?

The Colts are +107 to be the first team to reach 10 points, while the Steelers are -132.

The Colts have been the first to score 10 points in two of their four games this season.
The Steelers have also been the first to score 10 points in two of their four games.

First Quarter Moneyline

The Steelers are favored in the 1st Quarter Moneyline market, currently at -118, while the Colts are -102.

The Colts have a 1-3-0 first quarter W/L/T record this season, while the Steelers hold a record of 2-2-0.

Last Time They Met

The Steelers recorded a 27-20 victory over the Colts at Acrisure Stadium when these teams last met in Week 9, 2025. The Steelers have now won five straight at Acrisure Stadium against the Colts.